FC Cincinnati beats Orlando City 3-1 as Evander scores twice in MLS Wild Card
Martín Ojeda put Orlando ahead, but Evander equalized from the spot and struck again just after halftime. Samuel Gidi sealed a road win that sends Cincinnati into a series against Nashville.

FC Cincinnati beat Orlando City SC 3-1 at Inter&Co Stadium on Thursday, November 19, advancing from the Eastern Conference Wild Card match to Round One of the MLS Cup Playoffs. Martín Ojeda scored for the hosts in the 26th minute. Evander tied the match with a 43rd-minute penalty, put Cincinnati ahead in the 49th and set up Samuel Gidi's goal in the 85th. The No. 9 seed ended the No. 8 seed's season on its home field.
Orlando found room on the left before the opening goal. Marco Pašalić forced a save from Roman Celentano in the 24th minute. Two minutes later, Iván Angulo threaded a pass to Ojeda, whose left-footed shot from the left side of the area went into the bottom right corner. In a single-elimination match, the goal gave Orlando a chance to turn its early territorial control into a place in the next round. Cincinnati had to find an answer.
Ojeda's lead lasts until Evander's penalty
The hosts kept creating chances after going in front. Ojeda tested Celentano again in the 37th minute, and Antoine Griezmann had a shot from the middle of the box saved in the 39th. Cincinnati's equalizer came from a different kind of opening. Marco Pašalić fouled Pavel Bucha inside the area in the 41st minute; Evander converted the penalty with his right foot in the 43rd. The teams reached halftime tied 1-1.
Cincinnati made two changes at the break, bringing on Alvas Powell and José Andrés Martínez for Miles Robinson and Nick Hagglund. Four minutes into the second half, Maxime Crépeau stopped a Tom Barlow shot. The play-by-play then credited Barlow with setting up Evander, who scored from the center of the area for a 2-1 lead in the 49th minute. The level score had lasted only briefly after the restart, and Orlando now had to chase the game.
Orlando takes 27 shots, but Cincinnati finds the goals
Orlando interim coach Martín Perelman brought on Justin Ellis and Adrián Marín in the 53rd minute and Joran Gerbet in the 55th. Ojeda shot narrowly wide in the 55th and missed with a header in the 65th. Eduard Atuesta forced another Celentano save in the 80th. Orlando generated attempts throughout the half but never found the second goal it needed.
The final numbers show the gap between shot volume and finishing. Orlando outshot Cincinnati 27-10 and had 57.8% of possession. Both sides nevertheless put eight shots on target. Celentano made six saves; Crépeau made five. Cincinnati reached the target just as often with fewer overall attempts and scored on three of those eight shots. Orlando's edge in possession and total attempts was not enough to protect its season.
Evander contributed once more to settle the contest. Crépeau had saved a Tyrell Malacia shot in the 84th minute. In the 85th, Evander supplied Samuel Gidi in the middle of the area, and the midfielder placed a right-footed finish into the top right corner. Down 3-1, Orlando needed two goals in the closing minutes. Ellis and Griezmann still had late attempts, but the score held.
A Nashville series awaits Cincinnati
Our Orlando City–FC Cincinnati Wild Card preview noted how little separated the teams in the regular season: both finished on 46 points, while Orlando hosted because it had one more win. Cincinnati had scored 67 league goals but conceded 75. In the decisive game, its attack delivered three away goals despite Orlando's 27 shots.
Orlando's 2026 playoff run is over. Cincinnati advances to a best-of-three Round One series against Nashville SC, the East's top seed and Supporters' Shield winner. Game 1 is scheduled for Sunday, November 22 at 4 p.m. ET at GEODIS Park. Evander's two goals and his assist on Gidi's finish transformed an early deficit into the win that earned Cincinnati that next assignment.