FC Cincinnati at Orlando City: the East's two most-scored-on defenses meet with no extra time
Both finished on 46 points from 34 matches, separated only by wins. Orlando went 10-3-4 at Inter&Co and 3-4-10 on the road; Cincinnati has not lost to the Lions since October 2024.

Orlando City and FC Cincinnati ended the regular season on the same 46 points after the same 34 matches. One line of the rulebook splits them: the Lions won 13 games and Cincinnati 12, and total wins is the first tiebreaker in MLS. That line decides who plays at home on Thursday night, and home field carries unusual weight in this round. The Wild Card is settled in 90 minutes, and if the score is level there is no extra time. It goes straight to penalties.
Match details
- Competition: Audi 2026 MLS Cup Playoffs, Eastern Conference Wild Card.
- Teams: Orlando City SC (home, No. 8 in the East) vs. FC Cincinnati (away, No. 9).
- Date and time: Thursday, Nov. 19, 2026, 7:30 p.m. ET.
- Venue: Inter&Co Stadium, Orlando, Florida. Not a neutral site.
- Format: single match. If level after 90 minutes there is no extra time and the tie is decided on penalties, per the league's competition guidelines. The winner visits Supporters' Shield champions Nashville SC, who finished on 77 points, in a best-of-three Round One series beginning Nov. 22.
One team at home, another on the road
Orlando's season splits more cleanly by geography than by calendar. At Inter&Co Stadium the Lions went 10-3-4 and arrive unbeaten in their last seven home league matches. Away from Florida the record almost inverts, point for point: three wins, four draws, 10 defeats. A side that leans this heavily on its own field enters the postseason through the door that suits it best.
The bench is not the one that started the year, either. Óscar Pareja left on March 11 after Orlando lost its opening three matches, the last of them 5-0 in New York, and assistant Martín Perelman took over on an interim basis. Three days later Perelman's Orlando beat Montréal 2-1 for the club's first win of the season. Qualifying again extends the club's playoff run to seven straight seasons, the longest active streak in the league when Pareja departed.
Antoine Griezmann's summer arrival from Atlético Madrid raised the team's ceiling: 14 goals and eight assists in 18 appearances, with nine of Orlando's 13 wins coming after his July debut. Alongside him, Martín Ojeda scored 16 league goals and added five assists, numbers that made him the club's all-time leading scorer. The third name to watch is 19 years old. Justin Ellis delivered 11 assists and scored four minutes into his United States debut in September. In goal, Maxime Crépeau is back from the World Cup with Canada, as are Marco Pašalić with Croatia and Braian Ojeda with Paraguay.
Cincinnati took the opposite route in. It took points from each of its last three league road games, then lost 2-0 at home to Nashville on Decision Day, a result that dropped it from eighth to ninth — from hosting to travelling. Two figures explain its year: 67 goals scored, fourth-most in MLS, and 75 conceded. Evander was again the hub of everything with 14 goals and 17 assists, 31 goal contributions and a club record, while Kévin Denkey added 17 goals in his second season after arriving from Cercle Brugge for the largest fee the club has paid.
The two most-scored-on defenses in the East
The number that shapes this tie is not an attacking one. Orlando conceded 78 goals and Cincinnati 75: in that order, the two most-scored-on defenses in the Eastern Conference, and across MLS only Sporting Kansas City shipped more than the Lions. A win-or-go-home match between two sides that concede at that rate is rarely settled by possession.
Recent history leans toward the visitor. Cincinnati has not lost to Orlando since Oct. 5, 2024, a run of four league meetings without defeat, and coach Pat Noonan has yet to lose at Orlando's stadium. The heaviest blow came in May, a 6-2 win in Ohio, though August's trip to Florida finished 1-1. That asymmetry — a solid Orlando at home against the one opponent that has not lost there — is the knot of the match.
Tactically, the most interesting duel sets the Griezmann-Ojeda partnership against whatever back line Cincinnati can field on Thursday. If Noonan is short at the back, the margin for protecting a lead narrows; if Orlando does not close down its own box, the output of Evander and Denkey punishes any lapse. With penalties waiting at the end of 90 minutes, an early goal would reorder both game plans.
Availability report
MLS does not publish a mandatory injury report of the kind the NFL and NBA require. What follows comes from pre-match reporting dated Nov. 17, 2026; starting elevens are estimates until the official lineups, and the picture can change on Thursday itself.
Orlando City
- Griffin Dorsey: doubtful — back problem.
- Tyrese Spicer: expected to miss out — foot issue.
- Robin Jansson: expected to miss out — foot issue.
- Iago Teodoro: available again after serving a suspension.
FC Cincinnati
- Obinna Nwobodo: out — suspended for yellow-card accumulation.
- Nick Hagglund: likely absent — not expected to clear concussion protocol.
- Julián Malatini: doubtful — leg injury.
- Miles Robinson: the center back carried knocks through the closing weeks and his availability was affected by them; he played 90 minutes for the United States against Türkiye.
Nwobodo's suspension is the most measurable of these. It removes a holding midfielder in a match where Cincinnati will have to shield a back line that was already punished all season. If Hagglund and Malatini are also missing, Noonan would go into the tie with his thinnest defense of the year.
How to watch Orlando City vs. FC Cincinnati
- Venue: Inter&Co Stadium, Orlando, Florida.
- Date and time: Thursday, Nov. 19, 2026, 7:30 p.m. ET.
MLS stopped selling MLS Season Pass as a separate add-on in 2026. Every match, the playoffs included, now comes with an Apple TV subscription, with no blackouts, in more than 100 countries and regions, and with English and Spanish commentary. The Wild Card round has no linear television broadcast.
United States
- Streaming: Apple TV, 7:30 p.m. ET / 4:30 p.m. PT, with a Spanish-language commentary option.
United Kingdom
- Streaming: Apple TV, 12:30 a.m. GMT on Friday, Nov. 20.
Australia
- Streaming: Apple TV, 11:30 a.m. AEDT on Friday, Nov. 20 (10:30 a.m. AEST in Brisbane, 8:30 a.m. AWST in Perth).
Thursday's question
Orlando built its season on a field where it has gone seven league matches without defeat; Cincinnati arrives on a run of four straight meetings without losing to that opponent. One of the two streaks ends before midnight, and it could end from the penalty spot.