Razón y Saber
EspañolEnglish日本語

Colorado judge finds ICE official in contempt over immediate rearrest after court-ordered release

Charlotte Sweeney finds that her release order was disobeyed. She takes no further action because ICE's acting Denver director testified under oath that he had ended the practice of immediately rearresting people freed by judges.

Denver buildings in the distance, with trees, Ferril Lake and mountains beneath a blue sky.
Denver, Colorado, photographed in August 2015. © Carol M. Highsmith / Library of Congress · Archive

A federal judge in Colorado ruled Wednesday, November 18, that an Immigration and Customs Enforcement official and the government respondents were in contempt of court for rearresting a man immediately after he was released from detention under a judicial order. The ruling imposes no further sanction: the judge found that officials had cured their noncompliance by telling the court the practice had stopped.

U.S. District Judge Charlotte N. Sweeney's 15-page order concerns Ramon Quintero Alvarez. It traces how an order to free him led to another detention, examines the explanations of ICE's Denver leadership and sets out why escorting someone outside to arrest him again did not accomplish what the court required.

Quintero Alvarez has since been released. Sweeney therefore denied his remaining motions as moot and ordered the case closed. Her decision records a finding of contempt against ICE official Nichole Black and, by extension, the government respondents for the period before November 9.

A release that led straight back to custody

Quintero Alvarez, who was born in Mexico, sought release through a habeas corpus petition, a means of asking a court to review detention. According to the account in the order, he entered the United States with his mother in 1993 or 1994 and has not left the country since.

He testified that he had lived in Wyoming for about 12 years with his two sons, both U.S. citizens. The children were staying with their mother during his detention. The order says the government did not contest those facts or his assertion that his detention, which began in February 2026, was unlawful.

On October 20, Sweeney gave the government until October 27 to explain why his petition should not be granted. If officials failed to respond, they were required to release him within 24 hours of the deadline and subsequently report on compliance.

The required response did not arrive. A November 3 status report said Quintero Alvarez had been released on October 27, immediately detained again and kept in custody. Government lawyers also said they would not argue that his detention was lawful.

How ICE's Denver leadership explained the rearrest

Sweeney convened a hearing on November 4. Nichole Black, an assistant field office director for ICE in Denver, testified that she had received instructions to rearrest certain people released under court orders when their cases involved some form of criminal conduct, according to the judge's account.

Black described Quintero Alvarez receiving his belongings, walking through the lobby and going into a public area, where officers were waiting to arrest him again. She acknowledged knowing about the release order and believing that briefly taking him outside was enough to comply.

She also acknowledged that the information she had relied on about supposedly pending criminal charges was inaccurate. The order says the charges underlying Quintero Alvarez's most recent arrest had been dropped on April 24, 2026.

Acting Denver Field Office Director Nathan Rasper testified at a second hearing on November 9. He said colleagues in Minnesota had told him about rearrests and that he understood the approach could be used when a habeas release resulted from technical problems with documents.

Rasper maintained that the agency's legal advisers were supposed to review the cases. He described Black's understanding as an overly narrow version of his instructions and suggested a misunderstanding had played a part. Sweeney examined those explanations but found that they did not excuse disobedience of her order.

Why Sweeney found civil contempt

The judge applied three requirements: a valid court order, knowledge of the order by those required to follow it, and disobedience. She found that testimony and documents established all three through clear and convincing evidence.

Black knew that Quintero Alvarez was to be freed, Sweeney wrote. Taking him into a public area for immediate rearrest defeated the result the court had required. The judge also explained that civil contempt does not require proof that disobedience was willful.

One purpose of civil contempt is to secure compliance with judicial orders. In this case, Sweeney treated Rasper's sworn testimony that the practice had stopped as decisive. He said that after the November 4 hearing he had directed officials to end the immediate rearrests and release those detained under that approach.

At the November 9 hearing, Rasper assured the court that a person it ordered freed would no longer be released and immediately detained again in that way. Sweeney emphasized that his sworn commitment was binding on him.

At least 18 cases, and the agency's position

The record extended beyond one episode. The order notes that the number of known cases of immediate rearrest following judicial release grew from about 10 to 18. The American Civil Liberties Union of Colorado and law professor Elizabeth Jordan intervened through a friend-of-the-court brief.

The organization said it knew of at least 18 instances in Colorado in which people had been kept in detention despite release orders. Its intervention asked Sweeney to examine the practice and its effects on those detained and their families.

MPR News reported that people immediately rearrested between October 27 and November 4 had subsequently been released again. In a statement sent to the broadcaster the previous week, ICE said it could take further action, including rearrest when appropriate, consistent with the law and court orders.

Closing the case leaves the finding on record

Wednesday's order separates the finding of contempt from additional measures to remedy it. Sweeney found that Black and the government respondents had disobeyed the release order from the October 27 rearrest until the November 9 hearing, when the court received the commitment that the practice had ended.

Because she found the officials had cured their noncompliance, she declined further action. Quintero Alvarez's case is closed following his release, while the undertaking to respect judicial release orders remains part of the sworn testimony of ICE's acting director in Denver.